All articles
9 min read

Can a Private Investigator Make an Arrest? A License Adds No Power

A private investigator can make an arrest only as an ordinary private citizen, and only where state law allows it. The license adds no arrest power, and some states allow detention only.

By Sharon DeCet, Founder · Updated 12 Nov 2026

A private investigator sits in a parked car at dusk, watching a house through a camera with a long lens.

Key takeaways

  • A private investigator holds the arrest power of any private person and nothing more. California's licensing bureau states that a private investigator has no law enforcement authority, even when hired by law enforcement.
  • In the seven jurisdictions we compared, five let a private person arrest (California, Texas, Minnesota, New York, Ohio) and two allow detention only (North Carolina, Georgia). The crimes covered differ from state to state: misdemeanors are reached in California, Minnesota and New York, but only felonies and breaches of the peace in Texas, and only felonies in Ohio.
  • Georgia's 2021 law names licensed investigators, but only to permit detention that is needed in the licensed work, followed by release or a call to law enforcement.
  • Unless you can name your state's statute and show each of its elements from what you personally saw, our recommendation is to observe, document and call the police.
In this article
  1. 1Can a private investigator make an arrest under a private investigator license?
  2. 2What does each state's citizen's arrest law allow a private investigator to do?
  3. 3Why is a misdemeanor arrest the riskiest call for an investigator?
  4. 4What did Georgia change for licensed private investigators in 2021?
  5. 5What should a private investigator check before detaining or arresting anyone?
  6. 6What training covers the legal footing behind an arrest decision?
  7. 7Frequently asked questions

The same act can be lawful in one state and unlawful in the next. A person who watches someone smash a window in California may make an arrest. A person who sees the same thing in North Carolina may only detain, and must notify an officer immediately.

A private investigator stands in the same position as that person, so the answer changes with the state. In California, Minnesota and New York, a person who watches a misdemeanor happen may arrest. In Texas the offense must be a felony or a breach of the peace. In Ohio it must be a felony.

Getting it wrong has a cost, because a mistaken arrest exposes the person who made it, and California's licensing bureau warns of criminal liability for false arrest. Below are the seven rules side by side, Georgia's provision for licensed investigators, a six-question check to run before touching anyone, and the next step for readers whose state is not in the table.

Can a private investigator make an arrest under a private investigator license?

No. A private investigator license gives no arrest power. A licensed investigator may arrest only as a private person, the power commonly called a citizen's arrest, and only where state law allows one. The California Bureau of Security and Investigative Services states that a private investigator has no law enforcement authority "even if he/she has been hired by law enforcement," and that investigators "can only make citizen's arrests."

So the common assumption, "surely they can at least make a citizen's arrest," has a split answer. Yes, where the state lets anyone do it, on the same terms as anyone, with the same risk. Being hired by police changes nothing.

A license also does not let an investigator look like police. New York's licensing law makes it unlawful for a licensed investigator to display a badge in investigative work, or to make any statement that would reasonably cause another person to believe the licensee is a police officer (New York General Business Law §84, also reproduced in the New York Department of State licensing law compilation, March 2022). For a wider view of what a license does and does not cover, see our guide to private investigator laws.

What does each state's citizen's arrest law allow a private investigator to do?

It depends on the state. Of the seven jurisdictions we compared, five let a private person arrest and two allow only detention. We read the arrest provision of each in November 2026: California, Texas, Minnesota, New York, Ohio, North Carolina and Georgia. They are a sample, not a national count.

Jurisdiction and sourceArrest or detainWhat the law coversLicensed investigator
ArrestA public offense committed or attempted in your presence; a felony the person committed, even if not in your presence; a felony "in fact" committed where you have reasonable cause to believe this person did itSame as anyone
ArrestAn offense committed in your presence or within your view, if it is a felony or an offense against the public peaceSame as anyone
ArrestA public offense committed or attempted in your presence; a felony; a felony in fact committed with reasonable cause to believe this person did itSame as anyone
ArrestA felony the person has "in fact" committed; any offense the person has "in fact" committed in your presenceSame as anyone; no badge, no police impression
Arrest, felonies onlyA felony committed, or reasonable ground to believe one was, and reasonable cause to believe this person is guilty; you may "detain him until a warrant can be obtained"Same as anyone
Detain onlyProbable cause of a felony, breach of the peace, crime involving physical injury, or theft or property destruction, in your presence; you must notify an officer immediately and surrender the personSame as anyone
Detain onlyLicensees may detain "when needed in the performance of" their licensed businessNamed, for detention only

Three patterns come out of our count of these seven provisions:

  • None of the seven arrest provisions gives a licensed investigator extra arrest power. Georgia's is the only one that mentions licensees, and it permits detention, not arrest.
  • Three (California, Minnesota, New York) write "in fact" into the felony rule, meaning the felony must have actually happened.
  • Misdemeanors are the dividing line. California, Minnesota and New York reach any offense committed in your presence. Texas reaches only felonies and breaches of the peace. Ohio reaches only felonies.

A breach of the peace is an offense that disturbs public order. A felony is a serious crime; a misdemeanor is a lesser one.

If your state is not in the table, find its arrest statute in the official code published by the state legislature, and check the state licensing board's site for rules specific to investigators. Our guides to private investigator laws and private investigator license requirements by state are a starting point.

Why is a misdemeanor arrest the riskiest call for an investigator?

A misdemeanor arrest is the riskiest call because your own eyes are the only evidence the law accepts. In California, a private person who arrests for a misdemeanor without actually observing it in their presence "may be found criminally liable for a false arrest," according to the state licensing bureau's training manual (July 2023).

The manual's own example is plain. You see someone pick up a rock and throw it through a plate glass window: you may arrest. You hear glass break, run to the front, and find teenagers pointing at one of their friends and saying "he did it": you have no grounds, because you did not see it.

Felonies carry a different trap. The California, Minnesota and New York wordings require a felony that actually occurred. Our reading is that a reasonable but mistaken belief does not satisfy that wording, so the safest assumption is that a wrong guess is the arrester's risk. Ohio's wording is looser, since reasonable ground to believe a felony was committed is enough for that element, but Ohio still requires reasonable cause to believe this person is guilty.

This is why a flat "no, investigators can't arrest" is wrong in most states, and a flat "yes" is incomplete. The accurate answer is that investigators hold a private person's power, which is narrow, and where it is exercised wrongly the exposure falls on the person who made the arrest.

An investigator stands on a sidewalk at a distance, watching a storefront without stepping in.
A misdemeanor only counts if you saw it happen in your presence, so distance and a missed moment can make an arrest unlawful.

What did Georgia change for licensed private investigators in 2021?

Georgia took arrest powers away from licensees and gave them a narrower detention power. HB 479 (2021) repealed O.C.G.A. 43-38-13, the Code section on arrest powers of licensees and registrants. It also repealed the whole article on arrest by private persons, and created 17-4-80 (Georgia Office of the Governor, signed legislation).

Under 17-4-80(b)(5), a private person may detain someone if they are "a licensee or registrant under Chapter 38 of Title 43 when needed in the performance of his or her business conducted in conformance with such chapter." The same chapter covers private security businesses, so security licensees fall under the same clause (see can a security guard detain someone).

Three conditions follow:

  • Release or call. The person detained must be released, or law enforcement with jurisdiction must be contacted within a reasonable time.
  • Surrender. A person who is not released is surrendered to an officer together with any personal belongings removed from them.
  • Force. Except in defense of self or others, defense of a habitation, or preventing a forcible felony, the detainer may not use force "intended or likely to cause great bodily harm or death." Reasonable force necessary to detain is permitted.

If you work or plan to work in Georgia, our Georgia private investigator license guide covers the registration route.

What should a private investigator check before detaining or arresting anyone?

Run six checks, and treat any fail as a stop sign. These are our recommendations, built from the statutes in the table above.

An investigator at a desk reads a legal binder and takes notes under a lamp before deciding what to do.
Pausing to check the law and the facts first is what keeps a detention from becoming a false arrest.
  1. 1
    Did you see it yourself?
    Pass: you personally watched the offense happen or be attempted. Fail: a witness, a client or a bystander told you. For misdemeanors in every state in the table, this is a fail on its own.
  2. 2
    Is the offense one your state reaches?
    Pass: you can point to your state's row and the offense fits it. Fail: you cannot tell whether it is a felony, a misdemeanor or a breach of the peace.
  3. 3
    Does your state allow arrest, or detention only?
    Pass: you can say which, and what the law requires next. Fail: you are relying on a general idea of "citizen's arrest." North Carolina requires you to notify an officer immediately. Georgia requires release, or a call to law enforcement within a reasonable time.
  4. 4
    Can you name the statute?
    Pass: you have the citation and have read its current text. Fail: you are working from memory or a summary.
  5. 5
    Can you hand the person to an officer now?
    Pass: a call is placed and an officer is on the way. Fail: you plan to hold the person while you finish other work.
  6. 6
    Does your agency policy or client contract allow it?
    Pass: you have read the written policy and it permits the action. Fail: you have not read it, or it says to call police.

Any fail means: stop, observe, write down what you saw with times and positions, and call the police. Notes taken at the scene are what officers and prosecutors can use, and our guide to chain of custody shows what to log.

Learn the legal footing behind an arrest decision

Learningshopusa's Legal Aspects of Private Investigation course is self-paced and online, with 49 lessons and a certificate of completion, for $120.
View the course

Frequently asked questions

They have no special power to, and no duty to. A private investigator holds only a private person's arrest power, which is narrow in every state we compared. The safer course, in our judgment, is to record what was seen and call the police.
No. A private investigator cannot arrest on police authority or obtain a warrant, and may arrest only as a private person where state law allows. Impersonating an officer is unlawful, for example in New York under General Business Law §84.
Only as far as the law allows a private person, which is narrow. In Georgia, a licensee detaining someone may use reasonable force necessary to detain but not force likely to cause great bodily harm or death, except in defense of self or others. In North Carolina, detention must be reasonable in manner.
No. New York makes it unlawful for a licensed investigator to display a badge in investigative work or to make statements that would reasonably lead someone to believe they are a police officer. California's licensing bureau confirms investigators have no law enforcement authority.
The investigator can be held criminally liable for false arrest. In California, that applies to a misdemeanor arrest where the arrester did not see the offense. It also applies to a felony arrest where no felony was actually committed, even if the arrester had reasonable cause to believe one was (Penal Code 837).

Sources

  1. 1.California Bureau of Security and Investigative Services, Private Investigator FAQ
  2. 2.California Bureau of Security and Investigative Services, Powers to Arrest and Appropriate Use of Force Training Manual, July 2023
  3. 3.California Legislative Information, Penal Code 837
  4. 4.Texas Legislature, Code of Criminal Procedure Chapter 14, art. 14.01
  5. 5.Minnesota Office of the Revisor of Statutes, Minn. Stat. 629.37
  6. 6.New York State Senate, Criminal Procedure Law 140.30
  7. 7.New York State Senate, General Business Law §84
  8. 8.New York Department of State, Private Investigators, Bail Enforcement Agents, Watch, Guard or Patrol Agencies and Security Guards Licensing Law, March 2022
  9. 9.Ohio Revised Code 2935.04
  10. 10.North Carolina General Assembly, G.S. 15A-404
  11. 11.Georgia Office of the Governor, House Bill 479 as passed, 2021
  12. 12.Learningshopusa, Legal Aspects of Private Investigation course page

Keep reading

Learning Shop USA.

Trusted online certification since 2002.

© 2026 Learning Shop USA

Powered by PageLens.ai

Get in touch — we'd love to help.

Contact us